Author: Jachambers
With Golden State beating the Mavs, people have wondered if we should tamper with the playoff seeding rules once again so that the two best teams in the second round wouldn't have to play each other. After all Hockey does it, the NFL does it, so why shouldn't we do it? Some point to how the ratings would go up if you had the Spurs and Suns play in the semifinals rather than in the 2nd round. Others remind you of how Stern made a similar adjustment to this season's playoff seeding rules that succeeded in preventing another Spurs/Mavs matchup in the second round (well... technically Golden State also prevented that from potentially happening had the rules not been changed) and foresee him tampering with the rules again for the same reason.
The problem is, it’s not the same. What the previous rules tampering really did was keep teams like the 6th seeded Clippers last year from making it into the 2nd round so easily as a result of facing a horrible Nuggets team last year. It also prevented the Phoenix Suns from having such an easy trip to the semi-finals since they essentially went up against the 6th and 7th seeded teams on the way up there. Who this year has had an easy ride? The Golden State warriors? The Utah Jazz? They might have the easiest routes to the finals in the west, but far from being even close to how easy it was for Phoenix last year.

Now, I wouldn't kill myself if they put this rule into effect, I just think it's very unnecessary. These people cry about how easy it will be for the Warriors or the Jazz to make it to finals when they aren't even close to an elite team and ignore the fact that you have the Cleveland Cavaliers with around 50 wins with by far the easiest postseason schedule in the NBA. If you are going to fix the problem with the Spurs and Suns playing in the 2nd round, why not fix the problem of the Spurs and Suns playing in the semifinals also? Right now the Spurs and the Suns are probably the best two teams in the playoffs because the Eastern conference is so bad, they need to be playing in the finals. So if we are going to reseed the west, you might as well reseed the whole NBA so that the Suns and Spurs won't play until the finals.
With Golden State beating the Mavs, people have wondered if we should tamper with the playoff seeding rules once again so that the two best teams in the second round wouldn't have to play each other. After all Hockey does it, the NFL does it, so why shouldn't we do it? Some point to how the ratings would go up if you had the Spurs and Suns play in the semifinals rather than in the 2nd round. Others remind you of how Stern made a similar adjustment to this season's playoff seeding rules that succeeded in preventing another Spurs/Mavs matchup in the second round (well... technically Golden State also prevented that from potentially happening had the rules not been changed) and foresee him tampering with the rules again for the same reason.
The problem is, it’s not the same. What the previous rules tampering really did was keep teams like the 6th seeded Clippers last year from making it into the 2nd round so easily as a result of facing a horrible Nuggets team last year. It also prevented the Phoenix Suns from having such an easy trip to the semi-finals since they essentially went up against the 6th and 7th seeded teams on the way up there. Who this year has had an easy ride? The Golden State warriors? The Utah Jazz? They might have the easiest routes to the finals in the west, but far from being even close to how easy it was for Phoenix last year.

Now, I wouldn't kill myself if they put this rule into effect, I just think it's very unnecessary. These people cry about how easy it will be for the Warriors or the Jazz to make it to finals when they aren't even close to an elite team and ignore the fact that you have the Cleveland Cavaliers with around 50 wins with by far the easiest postseason schedule in the NBA. If you are going to fix the problem with the Spurs and Suns playing in the 2nd round, why not fix the problem of the Spurs and Suns playing in the semifinals also? Right now the Spurs and the Suns are probably the best two teams in the playoffs because the Eastern conference is so bad, they need to be playing in the finals. So if we are going to reseed the west, you might as well reseed the whole NBA so that the Suns and Spurs won't play until the finals.